spacer 1
Articles Home
Monthly Posts
Posts by Category
Spaceer 2
Contact Us
PHOENIX
5201 N. 7th Avenue
Phoenix AZ 85013
P. 602.952.6925
F. 888.202.0059
Map it →
TUCSON
190 W. Magee
Suite 182
Tucson AZ 85704
P. 520.229.3377
F. 888.202.0059
Map it →
EMAIL US TODAY
« Legislature inhibits sales in HOAS | Main
Friday
Jul312009

Pitfalls for agents on the boards of HOAS 

Agents often serve as directors on the Boards of the HOAs in which they reside. Service on the Boards serves the community in several ways. Agents bring real estate expertise to the Board. They bring financial expertise. As agents hoping for leads and sales, they are interested in preserving and enhancing property values. This motivation coincides with the interests of all the Members and the HOA. Agents are motivated to enforce the covenants to maintain the standards in the community.

Conflicts of interest can arise when an agent represents a homeowner in the community, if the agent also serves on the Board of Directors. Consider the following example. The homeowner hires the agent to sell the home. The homeowner is in financial difficulty. There is a trustee sale scheduled. The agent brings an offer that is sufficient to cover the first mortgage. However, there is not enough money to pay the delinquent HOA assessments in full. As a Director on the Board, can the agent try to persuade the other directors to compromise the HOA's assessments to close the deal?

Consider another transaction. The homeowner has a ramada that is visible from neighboring property. The homeowner did not submit the ramada for architectural approval. In its resale disclosure, the HOA lists the ramada as a violation. Can the agent serving on the Board try to convince the Board that the Board has waived the violation?

Arizona law has recently changed on conflicts of interest for directors on Boards of HOAs. This law firms encourages directors to think in terms of divided duties of loyalty, rather than conflicts of interest. In the scenarios described above, the agent has a duty of loyalty to the selling homeowner. The agent serving on the Board also has a duty of loyalty to the HOA. The duties collide, or are divided, in the scenarios above. The interests of the selling homeowners do not coincide with the interests of the HOAs. ARS sections 10-3860 to 3864 cover Director's Conflicting Interest Transactions. These laws provide legal protections to a director who has a conflict of interest on a transaction, if the director complies with the statute. The director must make a full and fair disclosure of the divided loyalty. The director should not participate in the deliberations on the matter. The director should not vote on the transaction. This law firm advises directors with divided loyalties to leave the room during the deliberation. If a majority of the Board approves the transaction under these circumstances, the director with the divided duty of loyalty receives legal protection.

Arizona law has changed on this point, but just for HOAs. The legislature passed HB 2311 effective August 2004. The bill is codified at ARS section 33-1811 for planned communities, and 33-1243(C) for condominiums. This new law provides that if there is a transaction on which a director has a divided duty of loyalty, the director must declare the conflict in an open meeting. The director must make the disclosure before the vote is taken. The covered transactions include those in which the spouse or family member has an interest. The statute provides that the director can vote on the transaction, if the director makes the disclosure. If the director does not make the disclosure, the transaction is void and unenforceable. The suggestion that the director can vote on the divided loyalty transaction is at odds with ARS sections 10-3860 to 3864.

In both scenarios set forth above and under ARS sections 3860 to 3864, this law firm still advises that the agent who serves on the Board should leave the room while the Board deliberates on the transactions. If the agent follows the new law for HOAs, makes the disclosure and votes on the issue, the agent still risks losing legal protection if the transaction is challenged. The new HOA law seems to "bait" directors to vote on divided loyalty transactions. Don't take the bait.

Reader Comments (8)

Well i just registered pn your forum i hope to find and share some great info, a lil of me im from sudamerica i got a lil website of diseño web thats web design in english u might check out sometime . Well im a very friendly person u can pm anything u want.I mean a spanish english translation or anything just send a pm

September 6, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterMikestorm34

Comfort in childbirth is a comprehensive natural childbirth preparation manual made easy.
Are you or a admired one awaiting a chick? Do you want a alternative childbirth? Needless to say, this can be a counteractive and agitating instance to say the least.
It seems there is so much to assimilate about natural childbirth that you may not feel. Whether this is your first child, or not, you want to be all ready for be-all and end-all and offer the best to your eagerly awaited adored one. Being properly educated and informed about normal childbirth is crucial regarding the health of the mother and infant for a successful natural childbirth.
Proper creation and coaching can make the advantage between a conquering and comfortable alternative childbirth versus a not so amicable or entangled experience from prepartum thru postpartum.
Natural Childbirth is possible.

September 10, 2010 | Unregistered Commentereuroda

I need to know exactly what Billy thinks with that.

Regards
Caroline

September 24, 2010 | Unregistered Commenteralcos insurance agency

Recently in Spain held a demonstration called Operation Teddy in which states that downloading music from the Internet is not a crime.The protesters gathered at the headquarters of the General Society of Authors and Editors of Spain (SGAE), using megaphones, laptops and posters announcing that in that space was downloading music from the Internet as part of the protest.The main purpose of this demonstration is to show that sharing files over the network means to promote freedom and technical knowledge, and should not be subject to copyright laws. The name "Operation Teddy" was because the group of protesters downloaded a song by Teddy Bautista, called Get On Your CNES.According to Xavier, a member of a group of hackers Metabolik laboratory belonging to the states "We claim the free flow of culture and technique against the digital divide that produce the lords of the copyright. A sustained breach of the outdated cultural industry and copy laws. "Is it validates the idea that downloading music and files from the Internet, is only one way to encourage technological culture?

September 24, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterMvenuss

The new distribution channel consisting in offering downloadable movies over the Internet is consolidating. Seems to begin to overcome the fears that the producers have had to this way of distributing content, in part, thanks to new anti-piracy systems (DRM), and partly I guess because of the successes already harvested by the Apple i-Tunes , through which has been offering legal downloads of music and later TV series. i-Tunes has demonstrated that this new form of distribution is not only a cost effective solution, but is destined to become the way to provide content for the future.In the United States already offers the service of Internet movie downloads such as Movielink and CinemaNow. The latter recently has added to its services from that after you download the movie burned to DVD for viewing on any player (even the titles offered are mediocre).

September 24, 2010 | Unregistered Commenterzopspovw

All greetings! I the first day at a forum. How are you?

September 26, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterGydaypeexthax

This site is dedicated to providing you with the best 3D TV related information, guides and news. Feel free to browse through our 3D TV list below, as well as our informative 3D TV guides and articles to learn more about this new and exciting display technology. We will also be reviewing the latest 3D Televisions to help you choose the best 3D TV for your home.
Be sure to read our comprehensive 3D TV guides listed below to help you learn everything you need to know to buy the best 3D TV for your home. Learn about the best plasma and LCD 3D TVs and the advantages of each technology so you can see through the manufacturer's hype and save money while buying the best available 3D TV for your home.

January 13, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterFrumvebuibe

HHH Yes, the design of national policy is important, how our economic development plans for the next five years, how the implementation, how to make our economy even faster. Are designed to advance our focus to invest money in what ways it should be carefully arranged. pubexn pubexn - Belstaff Outlet.

November 25, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterxksiyc xksiyc

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>