Suburban communities across Arizona, like Casa Grande, rely on homeowners’ associations (HOAs) to maintain order among residents. Enforcing the rules can be more legally complicated than you might think, and all HOAs should have a lawyer who can help.
Enforcing HOA rules requires following specific legal procedures. A deviation from these procedures could land the HOA board in hot water. HOAs should always review rules and procedures with attorneys before taking any legal action against a homeowner. Even handling common violations or unpaid fines and fees may require help from an attorney.
Contact our attorneys for boards and communities to request a private legal review by calling Halk, Oetinger, and Brown at (602) 759-9205.
Enforcing HOA Rules When Violations Occur
Violations of HOA rules are bound to happen. Many violations are unintentional, and homeowners might feel that the penalties are undeserved or unfair. In such cases, the HOA board may need a lawyer’s help to enforce the rules and collect fines.
Notification of the Violation
After a community member violates the rules, the HOA must notify them of the violation before imposing penalties. Often, this involves sending the community member a formal letter explaining the violation, when it was observed, and evidence of the violation (e.g., photos).
The HOA must also allow community members to cure the violation if possible. For example, before imposing fines for an uncut lawn, the homeowner must have a chance to mow the lawn to cure the violation. If the violation is not cured within a specific period, or a cure is not possible, the HOA may impose a fine.
HOA Hearings
Under Arizona law, homeowners accused of violating HOA rules may demand a hearing before the HOA board to defend themselves. If the homeowner requests a hearing, the HOA must arrange one. If this happens, the HOA should have a lawyer present. If the hearing does not end well, the attorney can advise the HOA on what to do next.
Fine Collection
After the homeowner has been officially notified of the violation and has had a hearing, if requested, the HOA may move forward with collection efforts. Again, the first notice the homeowner received should explain how to pay fines. If the homeowner refuses to pay, our attorneys for boards and communities can help initiate legal action to collect the debt.
Further Legal Action
When someone refuses to pay a fine, the HOA may take more serious legal action. One option is to settle the matter through mediation or arbitration. Many HOAs include mediation or arbitration clauses in their governing documents that require alternative dispute resolution before anyone can pursue a lawsuit.
If mediation or arbitration fails, a lawsuit may be possible. However, your HOA board should talk to a lawyer about this first. Lawsuits against homeowners can be tricky and sometimes create division within the community.
Can an HOA in Casa Grande Sue a Homeowner for Refusing to Comply with the Rules?
Yes. Homeowners are legally obligated to follow the HOA’s rules. These rules are covenants attached to a homeowner’s land title and are a binding contract that homeowners agree to when they purchase their home. If they refuse to adhere to the rules, they may be in breach of the agreement, the HOA may sue, and a court may order the homeowner to comply.
What if Homeowners in an HOA Fail to Pay Assessments?
Assessments are regular fees or dues that all homeowners in a community must pay. Assessments usually help the HOA cover operating costs and maintenance of community amenities. When someone fails to pay an assessment, the HOA may take legal action.
Liens
If assessments go unpaid in Arizona, the HOA may automatically place a lien on the homeowner’s property. The lien secures the debt for the HOA, and the only way to remove it is to pay the assessment.
Can We Negotiate?
Sometimes, community members do not pay assessments because they have fallen on hard financial circumstances. Can the homeowner pay their debt in monthly installments? Will they have the money in a month or two? Your lawyer can negotiate with the homeowner to reach an arrangement agreeable to all parties.
Foreclosure
If an alternative payment arrangement is not possible, the HOA may collect the debt by initiating foreclosure on the homeowner’s property. In Arizona, a homeowner must owe more than $10,000 in unpaid assessments or be delinquent with payment for more than 18 months for the HOA to foreclose.
How Often Should HOA Boards Meet with Lawyers?
Many associations meet regularly with a lawyer, even if no legal dispute is currently pending. Meeting several times a year, perhaps once per quarter, keeps the attorney up to date on everything happening with the HOA and any legal disputes that could arise in the near future. This way, the attorney is fully caught up if a dispute arises, and the HOA is prepared for legal action even on short notice.
Can Homeowners Sue an HOA in Casa Grande?
Your HOA may need a lawyer to take legal action against a homeowner. Homeowners may also sue the HOA under certain circumstances, and the HOA needs legal representation.
Breaching Governing Documents
The HOA’s rules and governing documents bind the HOA just as they do homeowners. If the HOA does something, or fails to do something, that breaches the community’s legal covenants, the HOA may be sued. For example, the HOA rules may require the HOA to maintain community amenities, like pools or community fitness centers. If these amenities fall into disrepair to the point they are unusable, someone could sue the HOA.
Arbitrary or Inconsistent Enforcement of Rules
The HOA must enforce the rules uniformly and consistently. When the HOA holds some community members accountable for violations but not others, it may face legal action. In some cases, homeowners accuse HOAs of acting discriminatorily, favoring certain community members over others for illegal reasons. If this happens in your HOA, you need a lawyer immediately.
Breach of Fiduciary Duty
The HOA is responsible for collecting, maintaining, and spending money on behalf of the entire community. HOA board members have a fiduciary duty to manage HOA finances in a way that best serves the community. Mismanaging or even stealing funds will almost certainly result in legal action against the HOA.
Contact Our Attorneys for Boards and Communities in Casa Grande for Legal Support
Contact our attorneys for boards and communities to request a private legal review by calling Halk, Oetinger, and Brown at (602) 759-9205.