A conflict of interest may be anything that could cause an HOA board member to act in their personal interests rather than the association’s. These conflicts may be minor issues or major concerns, but they should always be addressed with a lawyer.
If you discover a conflict of interest, alert your HOA board’s attorney immediately. The conflict must be properly disclosed, and the affected board member may need to recuse themselves from certain meetings or votes regarding the issue. The conflict of interest should be properly documented, including the disclosure and recusal, so that we have records and evidence just in case someone takes legal action against the board.
Contact our Arizona association governance attorneys to request a confidential case review by calling Halk, Oetinger, and Brown at (602) 759-9205.
What to Do if an HOA Board Member Has a Conflict of Interest
If a conflict of interest arises, affected HOA board members should meet with the HOA’s lawyer right away to discuss next steps.
Disclosure
Conflicts of interest must be disclosed to the community and the other board members. Ideally, conflicts of interest should be disclosed before they become a problem and affected board members can take steps to avoid the conflict. Disclosure can occur during a public meeting before the board votes.
Recusal
Recusal involves board members with conflicts of interest stepping back and choosing not to participate in a discussion, meeting, or vote where their conflict could prevent them from acting in the association’s best interests. Often, recusal is enough to resolve the issue, but it must happen before the board votes or makes a final decision.
Documentation of the Conflict
Thoroughly document the conflict of interest and everything that was done in response, including disclosures and recusals. If someone later takes legal action against the HOA or board members because of the conflict of interest, documentation showing the problem was addressed and resolved will aid the HOA’s defense.
Should You Call a Lawyer About an HOA Board Member’s Conflict of Interest?
Yes. When you realize the conflict of interest, it might seem insignificant, and you might be more than capable of preventing the conflict from interfering with your duties as a board member. Even so, conflicts of interest look bad. Our association governance lawyer will help you determine next steps, resolve the conflict of interest, and maintain community trust.
What Constitutes a Conflict of Interest for an HOA Board Member?
A conflict of interest may be a situation or relationship that could interfere with a board member’s ability to perform their duties fairly and impartially.
Financial Interests
Many conflicts of interest involve a board member’s financial interests. For example, the board may be ready to vote on which landscaping business to contract with for landscaping work in the community. If a board member owns a landscaping company that puts in a bid, they have a serious conflict of interest. Essentially, the board member could vote to hire their own landscaping business, thereby using their position on the board to enrich themselves.
Nepotism
Nepotism generally involves favoring family members in business decisions. Continuing the example above, if the owner of the landscaping business the HOA board is considering hiring is related to a board member, that board member has a conflict of interest. While the board may still vote to extend a contract to the landscaping business in question, the conflicted board member should not be involved in that decision.
Personal Gain and Perks
HOA boards are generally community volunteers. Being on the board is usually not a paid position. If a board member appears to be using their position to obtain perks, gifts, or payments of some kind, there may be a serious conflict of interest. Board members must not make decisions based on perks or gifts.
What Are the Rules Regarding Conflicts of Interest?
Your HOA should maintain a written policy regarding conflicts of interest and what to do when they arise. If you discover a conflict of interest, contact an attorney and consult the bylaws right away. Adhering to the rules is a great way to protect the HOA from liability for wrongdoing related to a conflict of interest.
Can an HOA Be Sued for Conflicts of Interest?
Yes. If homeowners in the community believe that a board member’s conflict of interest somehow harmed the community, they may initiate legal action against the HOA, including a lawsuit.
This may occur if evidence shows that a conflict of interest cost the HOA money or caused HOA funds to be misappropriated. For example, if a board member votes to hire their own landscaping company to do work in the community but fails to perform any work, they may be accused of using their board position to siphon HOA funds into their business and personal accounts.
Who Can Be Sued for a Conflict of Interest
Conflicts of interest may raise doubts about how the board handles HOA funds and where misappropriation or outright theft has occurred.
Suing the HOA
If there is evidence to suggest that the HOA ignored a conflict of interest and allowed a board member to vote on an important issue they should have been recused from, the HOA may be liable for things like funds lost.
Generally, individual board members are not sued, only the HOA. Under the “business judgment rule,” board members acting in furtherance of the HOA may be shielded from liability if their poor decisions were made in good faith, with reasonable care, and were believed to be in the best interests of the organization.
Personal Liability
If a board member is determined to have acted in bad faith, committed fraud, or abused their power for personal gain, the “business judgment rule” that would normally shield them from personal liability may be stripped away, and they may be sued.
What if a Board Member Does Not Realize They Have a Conflict of Interest?
This is a somewhat common problem, and many board members do not realize they have a conflict of interest until someone else brings it up.
Review upcoming board decisions with an attorney and talk about things like family members in the community, business interests, and whether they have anything to personally lose or gain based on the board’s actions.
Speak to Our Association Governance Attorneys About Your Situation Today
Contact our association governance attorneys to request a confidential case review by calling Halk, Oetinger, and Brown at (602) 759-9205.